If you like this post, please share:

If you liked this post, please share:

The September issue of Healthcare Design hit my desk last week, full of the best new projects to recently open their doors. I was struck by the contrast between that and the 15th century hospital I visited a few weeks ago in Beaune, France.

So many differences, and yet so many similarities. Just like the 259-year-old hospital in Philadelphia I wrote about in July.

The Hotel-Dieu in Beanne was built in 1443. What’s even more remarkable is that it provided care until 1971.  Now it’s a museum.

As a “palace for the poor,” for hundreds of years, the Hotel-Dieu was actually a hospice — a place where people (rich and poor) went to die.  Because back then, if you were sick enough to be taken to the hospital, you weren’t coming back home.

And while medicine has changed since the 15th century, I doubt very much that the kind of care the nuns gave to patients at the Hotel-Dieu was much different than today.

According to the National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization (NHPO), hospice focuses on caring, rather than curing. It provides help with pain management, as well as emotional and spiritual support.

Creating a peaceful, nurturing environment is also essential to hospice care.

At the Hotel-Dieu, poor patients were housed in the Great Hall of the Poors — a soaring cathedral-like space with rows of beds placed head-to-toe on either side (upper right).  Enclosed by on three sides, this arrangement made it easy for the nuns to tend to patients and also provided some degree of privacy.  Infection control, too?  Maybe.

Windows high above provided some light, but no real view to the outdoors. Without electricity, I imagine the place was rather dim most of the time. But that’s how things were then.

Richer patients were housed in smaller rooms with fewer beds and a few more niceties, like tapestries and paintings on the walls (early hospital arts programs!).

In one room, I spied a leather chair with a high back, canopy, wheels, and a lever on the side (left). The early beginnings of the modern patient room chair.

While I was fascinated with the Hotel-Dieu, it was rather dark and depressing. So, while hospice care maybe hasn’t changed that much since the 15th Century, hospice design has.

They’ve moved from being more clinical types of spaces to more residential and hospitality focused. (Read more.)

And while some of the freestanding hospice facilities being built today might not be intended for the poor, the NHPO says that hospice care in the U.S. is covered under Medicare, Medicaid, and most private insurance plans. Patients receive hospice care regardless of their ability to pay.

Same as in the 15th Century.

Bonus:  Check out this Hospitable Hospice experience design handbook that offers critical new thinking and a refreshing vision for re-imaging future hospices and services.

P.S.  Please do me a favor — if you liked this post and like this blog, please share it with others by sending them the link and/or post it on your Twitter, LinkedIn, or Facebook, etc.  Also, don’t forget to subscribe, so you’ll get emails when new content is posted.  Thanks!

publishing-2

Leave a comment



Michael Walsh

6 years ago

Great ….and sensitive blog.

Margaret Fleming

6 years ago

Does Medicare actually pay 100% for hospice?

Interesting thoughts and pictures on Hotel-Dieu. The curtains would have been a blessing in the major draft from the soaring ceiling.

Also, the thing I don’t see in Hotel-Dieu and wonder about in other hospice is a place where patient’s bed can be rolled to a sun-room, garden-view room, or other place for a few minutes of contact with other patients or even a chance to reach out and touch another hand.

Sara Marberry

6 years ago

There was a courtyard in the Hotel-Dieu, but I doubt that patient beds were moved out there. They were pretty fixed.

James Carrick

6 years ago

Great article – love the piece about early artwork.
Reminds us that sometimes our innovations are not so innovative after all. We just need to look to the past for inspiration.

Heather Ernst

6 years ago

I love this…so interesting that they called it a “hotel” which today entails a place of relaxation, rest, and often fun activities.

Sara Marberry

6 years ago

Most of the larger mansions and buildings in these old French towns were called hotels. According to Wikipedia, “hotel” in 15th Century France was a building seeing frequent visitors, and providing care, rather than a place offering accommodation.

Naomi Sachs

6 years ago

How timely! I am just covering this in my class, Foundations of Healthcare Design (filling in for Kirk Hamilton while he’s away this semester). I will pass it along.

Sara Marberry

6 years ago

Thanks, Naomi!

Sara_Marberry_Sq

Sara Marberry, EDAC, is a healthcare design knowledge expert, thought catalyst, and strategic marketing and business development consultant. The author/editor of three books, Sara writes and speaks frequently about industry trends and evidence-based design. She can be reached at sara@saramarberry.com.

Subscribe to My Blog!

Archives

@SaraMarberry on Twitter

Contact Me

Copyright 2019 © All Rights Reserved | Terms & Conditions